PDA

View Full Version : Almost Perfect - Young Adult Novel About Transgender Issues



MarieDelta
Jun 30, 2010, 8:31 PM
This looks interesting-


Almost Perfect by Brian Katcher takes place in the tiny rural town Boyer, Missouri with its own mini high school of 400 students. But it's not far from Columbia, Missouri, home of the University of Missouri (more commonly known as "Mizzou") a kind of progressive beacon which figures prominently in the book. Almost Perfect centers around the character of Logan, a senior who lives with his single mom in a mobile home (yes, she's a waitress at the local diner), runs with the school's hapless track team and is still devastated by the breakup with his long-time girlfriend, ice queen Brenda.


Into Logan's world comes Sage, a tall, freckled redhead with a quirky sense of style and cheeky humor who's the new girl in a school where everyone else has been together since kindergarten. Sage becomes Logan's lab partner (heavens to Twilight!) and there is, yes, immediate chemistry in the biology class. For the first time since his breakup, Logan comes out of his depression and becomes obsessed with Sage who, while very outgoing and fun in class, is reserved in one-on-one situations and had been home schooled for the past 4 years for mysterious reasons. Her family moved across state from a larger town to sleepy Boyer and Logan can't stop wondering why.

Early on in their friendship, Logan invites the parentally-cloistered Sage to a movie (she sneaks out with her sister's help). Logan is instantly rebuffed when he attempts to kiss her and is mystified why Sage's freshman little sister, Tammi, has seemingly way more leeway from her family than the 18-year old Sage. In starts and stops, the two young people are drawn closer and closer. The day after Thanksgiving, Logan confides all his shameful secrets to Sage... his ex cheated on him and his dad abandoned their family. The next day, Sage calls Logan to her and shares the reason for her homeschooling and strict upbringing. You guessed it, Sage tells him, "I'm a boy."


Almost Perfect rather brilliantly focuses on Logan's conflictual attraction-repulsion towards Sage better than any other book on trans issues I've encountered. He immediately leaves her and is disgusted and confused by his love for her. The author creates an excellent portrayal of erotically-charged transphobia. Logan has shame for being genuinely drawn towards Sage and, at the same time, profound shame for the shabby way he's treating her.

As the book develops, Sage and Logan end up visiting Mizzou together and, due to his sister's ministrations, end up spending the night together with an intimate, physical (yet non-sexual) connection. Laura, Logan's very accepting sister, inadvertently finds out about Sage's trans history, tells her brother about it and now Logan must deal with the fact that "his secret" is shared by another human being. His inner conflict about Sage and his knee-jerk reaction towards her becomes more intense. Without giving too much of the story away, there is a bashing and one of the two young people ends up on suicide watch.


I will be looking for this at my local bookstores :D

Let you know what I think :bigrin:

DuckiesDarling
Jun 30, 2010, 8:36 PM
I will be looking for this as well, Marie. Though honestly I feel the stigma would be because he was viewing Sage as a woman and was attracted to a woman. I wonder if he would have felt differently if she was post op. From what you posted it looks like it will a good read for all sexualities. Nothing in life is as rewarding as learning a life lesson, even though another's fictional eyes.

MarieDelta
Jun 30, 2010, 8:40 PM
I will be looking for this as well, Marie. Though honestly I feel the stigma would be because he was viewing Sage as a woman and was attracted to a woman. I wonder if he would have felt differently if she was post op. From what you posted it looks like it will a good read for all sexualities. Nothing in life is as rewarding as learning a life lesson, even though another's fictional eyes.

Yes, except you cant be post op untill you are older than 18...

DuckiesDarling
Jun 30, 2010, 8:41 PM
Yes, except you cant be post op untill you are older than 18...

But going to college would make Sage older than 18 I would think. But I'll be waiting for the book and see how the author deals with the situation. Sounds like an excellent read.